Politicians Make Promises With No Binding Obligation To Deliver
On
- Commentary, Politics
-
Why it won’t go anywhere:
-
The Constitution protects broad political speech. Campaign promises are legally treated as opinions or aspirations, not contracts.
-
Courts generally won’t police political lies — they leave it to voters, the press, and opponents to challenge them.
-
Politicians intentionally keep promises vague (“I’ll fight for better healthcare”) so they can’t be measured easily.
-
-
Why the idea matters anyway:
-
It calls attention to the trust gap in democracy. People are sick of being sold hype with no follow-through.
-
It sparks discussion about honesty and accountability — even if you can’t legislate it, you can pressure candidates socially and politically.

-
-
Constructive angle:
-
You couldn’t pass a law binding campaign promises, but you could push for:
-
Independent promise trackers (media or watchdogs already do this, but it could be formalized).
-
Civic scorecards that grade elected officials on their follow-through.
-
Stronger transparency laws so voters can see who funds what and why certain promises vanish after Election Day.
-
-

Comments are Disabled