Skip to content
“Admitting I was fooled would mean admitting I was wrong — and I can’t do that.”
On June 21, 2025 by
Elephants Room With
0 Comments
-
commentary
It’s one of the most troubling and fascinating questions of our time — and it speaks to the psychology of belief more than just logic or fact.
Here’s a breakdown of why people believe obvious lies:
1. Identity Over Accuracy
People tend to prioritize group identity over objective truth. If a belief signals loyalty to a group they value (political, religious, cultural), they will often defend it — even when it’s demonstrably false.
Example: “If my tribe says the sky is green, then saying it’s blue makes me a traitor.”
2. Repetition Breeds Belief
Even obvious lies, when repeated enough, start to feel true. This is known as the illusory truth effect. The more often we hear something — even if it’s absurd — the more familiar and comfortable it feels.
“I don’t know why I believe it… I’ve just heard it so many times.”
3. Emotion Beats Reason
Lies that appeal to fear, anger, or hope override logic. Emotionally charged stories activate the parts of the brain responsible for survival and intuition — not careful analysis.
“It just feels true. I don’t need proof.”
4. Cognitive Dissonance
People resist facts that contradict their worldview because it creates psychological discomfort. Believing the lie becomes easier than facing the possibility that they were wrong all along.
“Admitting I was fooled would mean admitting I was wrong — and I can’t do that.”
5. Mistrust of Institutions
When trust in media, science, or government erodes, people turn to alternative sources — often unvetted or manipulative ones. Lies seem more credible in a world where nothing seems trustworthy.
“Everyone lies anyway. At least this guy seems honest.”
6. Social Reinforcement
People are heavily influenced by what others around them believe. If everyone in their circle buys the lie, challenging it can mean isolation, ridicule, or conflict.
“I’d rather be wrong with them than right and alone.”
7. The Lie Is Convenient
Sometimes the lie is just easier, simpler, or more emotionally satisfying than the truth. Especially if the truth is complicated, painful, or undermines one’s self-image or worldview.
“It’s not that I believe it… I just like what it lets me believe about myself.”
If you’re seeing this dynamic in politics, media, or personal conversations — you’re not alone. This is where misinformation gains power: not through logic, but through human psychology.
Post Views: 0
“Admitting I was fooled would mean admitting I was wrong — and I can’t do that.”
It’s one of the most troubling and fascinating questions of our time — and it speaks to the psychology of belief more than just logic or fact.
Here’s a breakdown of why people believe obvious lies:
1. Identity Over Accuracy
People tend to prioritize group identity over objective truth. If a belief signals loyalty to a group they value (political, religious, cultural), they will often defend it — even when it’s demonstrably false.
Example: “If my tribe says the sky is green, then saying it’s blue makes me a traitor.”
2. Repetition Breeds Belief
Even obvious lies, when repeated enough, start to feel true. This is known as the illusory truth effect. The more often we hear something — even if it’s absurd — the more familiar and comfortable it feels.
“I don’t know why I believe it… I’ve just heard it so many times.”
3. Emotion Beats Reason
Lies that appeal to fear, anger, or hope override logic. Emotionally charged stories activate the parts of the brain responsible for survival and intuition — not careful analysis.
“It just feels true. I don’t need proof.”
4. Cognitive Dissonance
People resist facts that contradict their worldview because it creates psychological discomfort. Believing the lie becomes easier than facing the possibility that they were wrong all along.
“Admitting I was fooled would mean admitting I was wrong — and I can’t do that.”
5. Mistrust of Institutions
When trust in media, science, or government erodes, people turn to alternative sources — often unvetted or manipulative ones. Lies seem more credible in a world where nothing seems trustworthy.
“Everyone lies anyway. At least this guy seems honest.”
6. Social Reinforcement
People are heavily influenced by what others around them believe. If everyone in their circle buys the lie, challenging it can mean isolation, ridicule, or conflict.
“I’d rather be wrong with them than right and alone.”
7. The Lie Is Convenient
Sometimes the lie is just easier, simpler, or more emotionally satisfying than the truth. Especially if the truth is complicated, painful, or undermines one’s self-image or worldview.
“It’s not that I believe it… I just like what it lets me believe about myself.”
If you’re seeing this dynamic in politics, media, or personal conversations — you’re not alone. This is where misinformation gains power: not through logic, but through human psychology.